• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Opinions
    • Top 30
    • Research
    • Supply Chain
    • Device Sectors
    • Directory
    • Events
    • Resources
    • Microsites
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Top 30
  • Research
  • Supply Chain
  • Device Sectors
  • Directory
  • Events
  • Resources
  • Microsites
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Reprints
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Pharmaceutical Focus: A Look at Combination Products

    The Printed World: Additive Manufacturing in Medtech

    The Lost Year: 2020 Year in Review

    Extrusion Evolution

    Little Big Parts: Micromolding Under the Microscope
    OEM News
    Supplier News
    Service / Press Releases
    Online Exclusives
    Press Releases
    People in the News
    Product & Service Releases
    Supplier News
    Medtech Makers
    Technical Features
    International News
    Videos
    Product & Service Releases
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Kwivik Therapeutics, EirMed Partner to Accelerate Product Commercialization

    Europe Marks its First Successful Remote Robotic-Assisted Coronary Angioplasty

    Twist on Heart Valve Design Boosts Blood Flow, Prevents Clots

    FDA Clears 3D Acellular Dermal Matrix

    Inogen to Undergo Leadership Transition
    From the Editor
    Blogs
    Guest Opinions
    Top Opinions
    Pharmaceutical Focus: A Look at Combination Products

    The Printed World: Additive Manufacturing in Medtech

    The Lost Year: 2020 Year in Review

    Extrusion Evolution

    Little Big Parts: Micromolding Under the Microscope
    Top 30 Medical Device Companies
    Market Data
    White Papers
    Top Research
    Fixing Face Mask Form and Function

    The Heart of the Matter: Trends in Cardiology

    Virtually the Same? The Challenges of Online Conferences

    Digital Health Delivers During a Year for the Ages

    Advanced Technology for Staking and Swaging Medical Plastics
    3D/Additive Manufacturing
    Contract Manufacturing
    Electronics
    Machining & Laser Processing
    Materials
    Molding
    Packaging & Sterilization
    R&D & Design
    Software & IT
    Testing
    Tubing & Extrusion
    Cardiovascular
    Diagnostics
    Digital Health
    Neurological
    Patient Monitoring
    Surgical
    Orthopedics
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Capabilities
    Add New Company
    Outsourcing Directory
    Medicoil

    PTI Engineered Plastics Inc.

    Element

    MW Life Sciences

    Unicep
    MPO Summit
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live From Show Event
    Industry Associations
    Videos
    Career Central
    eBook
    Slideshows
    Top Resources
    Meeting Critical Ventilator Product Requirements Amid Pandemic

    Impact of COVID-19 on the Medtech Supply Chain

    Finding the Upside to a Challenging Year

    Preparing Your Design Controls for FDA Approval

    A 'Trial and Error' Approach to Micromolded Parts
    Companies
    News Releases
    Product Releases
    Press Releases
    Product Spec Sheets
    Service Releases
    Case Studies
    White Papers
    Brochures
    Videos
    Outsourcing Directory
    Medbio LLC

    Creganna Medical, part of TE Connectivity

    K-Tube Technologies

    PTI Engineered Plastics Inc.

    Concise Engineering
    • Magazine
      • Current/Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Editions
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • News
    • Directory
      • All Companies
      • ALL CATEGORIES
      • Industry Associations
      • Company Capabilities
      • Add Your Company
    • Supply Chain
      • 3D/Additive Manufacturing
      • Contract Manufacturing
      • Electronics
      • Machining & Laser Processing
      • Materials
      • Molding
      • Packaging & Sterilization
      • R&D & Design
      • Software & IT
      • Testing
      • Tubing & Extrusion
    • Device Sectors
      • Cardiovascular
      • Diagnostics
      • Digital Health
      • Neurological
      • Patient Monitoring
      • Surgical
      • Orthopedics
    • Top 30 Company Report
    • Expert Insights
    • Slideshows
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Resources
    • eBook
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Research
      • White Papers
      • Case Studies
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Market Data
    • MPO Summit
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Microsite
      • Companies
      • Product Releases
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Services
      • White Papers / Tech Papers
      • Press Releases
      • Videos
      • Literature / Brochures
      • Case Studies
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise with Us
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Columns

    Patent Law: How OEMs and CMs Can Work Together

    ...

    Patent Law: How OEMs and CMs Can Work Together
    Related CONTENT
    • OptraSCAN Announces Expansion of Medical Advisory Board
    • Engineers Use 'Shrinky Dinks' to Develop Wearable Respiration Monitor
    • Electrophysiology Expert Joins BioSig Technologies Management Team
    • FDA Clears United Imaging Healthcare's uEXPLORER Total-Body Scanner
    • CEO of Medigus Steps Down
    Megha Manjunath and Doug Portnow, Schwegman, Lundberg & Woessner03.07.19
    It is often more cost effective for a medical device company to outsource product development , component manufacturing, or assembly work to a contract manufacturer (CM) since the CM often has the proper equipment, technical expertise, and experience. Many medical device companies and CMs work together in mutually rewarding business relationships that can last for many years. In some situations, however, the relationship can quickly sour and may end up in a legal dispute that can consume time, money, and emotional energy from both sides.

    One such battle can involve the ownership of intellectual property (IP) developed during a business relationship between the device company and the CM. The problem may occur when one of the companies invents something related to the project the two companies are working on together, and that company files a patent application on the invention. If certain considerations are not addressed upfront in contractual agreements, disputes can result that involve complex legal issues, including ownership of the patent. Further, the ill will generated when one company feels the other company misappropriated an invention can be fatal to the relationship.

    This article’s focus is on patent ownership principles. Although not exhaustive, there are some suggested practices companies can take to preserve their intellectual property rights. It is always advised, however, to communicate with your IP counsel to ensure adequate protection of your company’s inventions.

    A Brief Introduction to Patent Law
    The United States patent laws were founded in the U.S. Constitution. A patent provides its owners the right to exclude others from making, using, selling, or offering to sell the patented invention in the United States. This right is provided in exchange for full disclosure of the invention. The grant of a patent incentivizes creation and rewards disclosure of the invention. Disclosure of the invention can be instrumental in furthering innovation by others. Thus, the patent system strives to promote innovation rather than encouraging inventors to keep their scientific discoveries a secret for a competitive advantage.

    Inventorship vs. Ownership
    In the United States, a patent, by default, is granted to the inventor. Therefore, in the default case, the inventor is also the owner of the patent. The inventor, however, may assign his or her interest in the patent to another entity, such as another person or company. In that case, the patent owner may be different from the inventor. Inventorship and ownership of patents are distinct, yet often intertwined, issues.

    An inventor is an individual who conceived of the invention claimed in the patent. The inventor, however, is not necessarily the same person who reduced the invention to practice. Thus, if a person implements an invention (e.g., codes or builds) under the direction of someone else who conceived the actual invention, then that person does not qualify as an inventor.

    An owner of a patent enjoys all the rights granted by the patent without requiring approval from a co-owner. For example, an owner can license patent rights to third parties, sell the patent, or sue anyone who infringes the patent.

    To ensure your company is the sole owner of its patents, it is important to have thorough agreements that address assignment of IP. Without an agreement, the line between ownership and inventorship may become blurred and cause complications in patent enforcement.

    Potential IP Problems
    Following are three hypothetical scenarios in which a medical device company enters into a business relationship with a CM for the manufacture of a medical device.

    In the first example, a company provides the CM with design specifications of the device and the contract manufacturer builds the device as directed. The device company files a patent application on the device. The contract manufacturer demands a share of patent rights. Here, the CM has not contributed to the conception of the invention. Instead, the CM has simply implemented the invention under the direction of the device company. The contract manufacturer is not an inventor and has no ownership rights to the patent absent any agreement stating otherwise.

    In the second example, the CM builds the part as directed. An employee of the CM discloses details of the device to a large company that builds the device and adds functionality to the original device. The large company files a patent on the modified device. The first medical device company subsequently files a patent on the original device. Here, the first medical device company will suffer from a loss of patent rights because it did not file a patent in a timely manner. The United States patent system follows a “first to file” rule that grants the patent to an inventor who is first in time to file, and thus the large company will prevail.

    Finally, for the third example, assume the CM builds the device but adds functionality the medical device company did not originally conceive in its initial design specifications. The device company files a patent application directed to the device as disclosed by the design specifications and the added functionality. The contract manufacturer demands a share of patent rights. In this scenario, an employee of the CM has now contributed to the conception of the invention, and thus is an inventor. If this employee is obligated to assign the invention to the CM, the CM is now a joint owner of the patent absent any agreement stating otherwise.

    Jointly owned IP refers to IP developed by two or more parties. Here, the CM and the company may have joint ownership of the patent. It is generally advised against owning jointly owned IP for several reasons. Both the CM and the device company may now have full rights to the invention without the consent of the other. Filing and drafting the patent may become more complex and expensive. Both owners may license the patent, thus diluting the overall value of the patent. Differences in intellectual property law in various jurisdictions may also add complexity to patent enforcement if either the company or the contract manufacturer are based in a foreign country.

    Standard Solutions
    As has been demonstrated from the examples, it is important to include basic conditions in any agreement between a company and a contract manufacturer regarding intellectual property. On the other hand, filing a patent application on an invention before outsourcing development work or manufacturing can be an initial safeguard. Experienced legal counsel can work with a company to draft a patent application directed to the invention and foreseeable variations of the invention, thereby securing IP rights and preventing any future confusion. If filing a patent ahead of time is not possible, consider including terms in the agreement about breach of confidential information in a non-disclosure agreement.

    Regardless, ownership of any inventions conceived during the business relationship is a critical aspect that must be addressed. The contract manufacturer may feel the inventions were conceived of using their resources or their employees, and therefore, feel they should own the invention. On the other hand, the medical device company may feel that without having engaged the CM and paying for the work, no inventions would have even been developed by the contract manufacturer, and hence, they should own the invention. Therefore, ownership should be negotiated early in any relationship.

    One potential compromise is the granting of a license to the other party to allow them to have access to the technology. The scope of the license may be restricted in terms of field of use, a time limit, geographical constraints, or any other limitation that can be negotiated. These licenses are often royalty-free and exclusive, but in some situations, the license may not be exclusive and may require payment of royalties.

    Other broad terms can be addressed upfront, including the ability to assign the intellectual property or sublicense it with or without consent by the other party. These are only the very basic licensing terms that should be addressed, and it may be appropriate to address other licensing terms. Thus, it would be prudent to have seasoned legal counsel to guide you through this process.

    Other Considerations
    One other issue both parties should keep in mind is most governments have complex rules about exporting technology out of the host country. This is most relevant to the medical device company or the CM in terms of where the invention was conceived and the citizenship and residency of the inventors. Some countries will require patent applications to be filed in the country where the invention was conceived or where the inventor is a citizen, rather than just simply filing in the United States first without obtaining the required government approvals. Thus, one party may file a patent application in a foreign country while the other party is completely unaware of the action.

    Working with universities can also have a unique set of complex issues related to ownership of the IP. Therefore, it is recommended to work with experienced patent counsel to develop agreements that remove the risk of IP ownership issues when working in this type of relationship.

    Conclusion
    Although outsourcing to contract manufacturers may pose a risk to your company’s intellectual property rights, it is important to realize there are several safeguards in place that, if properly instituted, can greatly minimize any potential harm. An agreement between the two parties that outlines basic agreed upon terms, such as ownership and access to intellectual property developed during the business relationship, will go a long way in resolving potential future legal conflicts. 


    Megha Manjunath is a registered patent agent and associate at Schwegman, Lundberg & Woessner. Her practice focuses on prosecuting patents relating to the software arts. Manjunath received her J.D. degree from Santa Clara University and her B.S. degree in computer science from the University of California, Los Angeles.

    Doug Portnow is a registered patent attorney and principal at Schwegman, Lundberg & Woessner. His practice focuses primarily on medical device patent preparation, prosecution, and intellectual property due diligence. Prior to entering the legal profession, Portnow was a medical device engineer designing various medical products.
    Related Searches
    • first
    • medical device companies
    • medical
    • Outsourcing
    Related Knowledge Center
    • R&D & Design
    • Contract Manufacturing
    Suggested For You
     OptraSCAN Announces Expansion of Medical Advisory Board OptraSCAN Announces Expansion of Medical Advisory Board
    Engineers Use Engineers Use 'Shrinky Dinks' to Develop Wearable Respiration Monitor
    Electrophysiology Expert Joins BioSig Technologies Management Team Electrophysiology Expert Joins BioSig Technologies Management Team
    FDA Clears United Imaging Healthcare FDA Clears United Imaging Healthcare's uEXPLORER Total-Body Scanner
    CEO of Medigus Steps Down CEO of Medigus Steps Down
    5 Tech Investments for Accelerating Medical Device Manufacturing Growth 5 Tech Investments for Accelerating Medical Device Manufacturing Growth
    Wireless Wireless 'Pacemaker for the Brain' Could Offer New Treatment for Neurological Disorders
    Nu-Med Plus Advances Blood and Plasma Transfusion Technology With New Patent Nu-Med Plus Advances Blood and Plasma Transfusion Technology With New Patent
    BioSig Technologies Announces New Research Program With Mayo Clinic BioSig Technologies Announces New Research Program With Mayo Clinic
    Titan Medical Gains Seven Patents for Single-Port Robotic Surgery Titan Medical Gains Seven Patents for Single-Port Robotic Surgery
    No Bleeding Required: Anemia Detection via Smartphone No Bleeding Required: Anemia Detection via Smartphone
    RSNA News: University of Vermont Professor Joins RSNA Board of Directors RSNA News: University of Vermont Professor Joins RSNA Board of Directors
    Organizational and Regulatory Influences on Creating and Sustaining an Effective QMS Organizational and Regulatory Influences on Creating and Sustaining an Effective QMS
     Geneva Health Solutions Launches Geneva University Geneva Health Solutions Launches Geneva University
     TransEnterix Receives FDA 510(k) Clearance for 3mm Diameter Instruments TransEnterix Receives FDA 510(k) Clearance for 3mm Diameter Instruments

    Related Columns

    • Contract Manufacturing
      So Many Changes in Medtech, So Short a Time

      So Many Changes in Medtech, So Short a Time

      This article looks at the general state of medtech/life sciences M&A and the outsourcing trends triggered by the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic.
      Mark Bonifacio, President, BCS LLC 10.01.20

    • Contract Manufacturing | R&D & Design
      Trends for Medtech Contract R&D and Manufacturing

      Trends for Medtech Contract R&D and Manufacturing

      Over the past 10 years, medtech manufacturers from startups to giants have grown their levels of outsourcing to contract R&D and manufacturing partners.
      Maria Shepherd, President and Founder, Medi-Vantage 09.01.20

    • Contract Manufacturing
      Smart Sourcing: Transforming the Supply Chain Into a Value Network

      Smart Sourcing: Transforming the Supply Chain Into a Value Network

      The rise of globalization and outsourcing has led to increased supply chain risk and decreased predictability due to variability and complexity.
      Daniel R. Matlis and Sandra K. Rodriguez, Axendia Inc. 09.01.20


    • R&D & Design | Surgical
      Sparking Innovation as We Struggle to Find the New Normal

      Sparking Innovation as We Struggle to Find the New Normal

      The goal is to find the best ideas to support orthopedic patients adjusting to additional pain and immobility while they wait for elective surgeries.
      Dawn A. Lissy, Founder & President, Empirical 06.04.20

    • Contract Manufacturing
      Shopping Smart: What to Look for in a Contract Manufacturer

      Shopping Smart: What to Look for in a Contract Manufacturer

      A contract manufacturing organization can help shoulder the workload of bringing a new device to market.
      Claudio Hanna and Jennifer Ponti, Web Industries Inc. 06.04.20

    • R&D & Design
      Disposable Design: Consider All Interfaces

      Disposable Design: Consider All Interfaces

      The disposable component is becoming more challenging as products get smaller and more complex.
      Will DeMore, Mechanical Engineer, Key Technologies Inc. 06.04.20


    • R&D & Design
      Why Outsourcing Is in: Piecing Out Projects Makes Sense

      Why Outsourcing Is in: Piecing Out Projects Makes Sense

      Getting outside help is a trend both large and small medical device companies are following as outsourcing engineering services continues to gain traction.
      Dawn A. Lissy, President & Founder, Empirical 04.01.20

    • R&D & Design
      Top 10 Considerations for Medtech Inventors

      Top 10 Considerations for Medtech Inventors

      If you or your employer is interested in protecting an invention, then filing a patent application may be the way to go.
      Ryan Connell and Doug Portnow, Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner 04.01.20

    • R&D & Design
      Supercharge Medical Device Innovation Using Effective User Preference Studies

      Supercharge Medical Device Innovation Using Effective User Preference Studies

      User preference and evaluation studies have been a mainstay design tool for medical device development for decades.
      Philip Remedios, Principal, Director of Design & Development, BlackHägen Design 04.01.20


    • Contract Manufacturing
      A Valuable Supply Chain Lesson, Courtesy of Coronavirus

      A Valuable Supply Chain Lesson, Courtesy of Coronavirus

      The deadly respiratory disease spreading like wildfire around the world is exposing major weaknesses in the global medtech supply chain.
      Michael Barbella, Managing Editor 03.04.20

    • Contract Manufacturing
      The Seychelles—A Solution for Niche Production

      The Seychelles—A Solution for Niche Production

      Geographic location, free trade agreements, and an educated workforce make the location an excellent fit for the right manufacturer.
      Jude Shroff, Managing Director, Chelle Medical Ltd. 03.04.20

    • Contract Manufacturing
      Supply Chain Risk Monitoring: Playing 20 Questions

      Supply Chain Risk Monitoring: Playing 20 Questions

      Whether an earthquake or the spread of the coronavirus, recent incidents highlight the reality and complexity associated with managing a global supply chain.
      Ryan Oleksy, Co-Founder, Next Life Medical Corporation; Advisor, Sauron Group 03.04.20


    • Contract Manufacturing
      How Medical Product Outsourcers Can Compete on Quality in 2020

      How Medical Product Outsourcers Can Compete on Quality in 2020

      Outsource firms are reshaping medical device manufacturing as nearly every leading OEM turns to them to effectively compete on time-to-market and pricing.
      Louis Columbus, Principal, IQMS 01.29.20

    • R&D & Design | Testing
      FDA Guidelines for Employing X-ray Inspection in Medical Device Development

      FDA Guidelines for Employing X-ray Inspection in Medical Device Development

      Different materials exhibit different radiopacity as a function of material composition (i.e. atomic weight) and thickness.
      Gil Zweig, President, Glenbrook Technologies 01.29.20

    • Digital Health | R&D & Design
      Speed Up or Risk Stepping Down: The New Reality of the Connected Healthcare Development Cycle

      Speed Up or Risk Stepping Down: The New Reality of the Connected Healthcare Development Cycle

      Digital health and connected devices are an extraordinary new tool for delivering on improving patient outcomes.
      Joe McBeth, VP Global Supply Chain, Jabil Healthcare 01.29.20


    Trending
    • Senseonics Forges Strategic Collaboration With Ascensia Diabetes Care
    • Portable, Home-Use Device Quickly Measures Inflammation Levels
    • Henry Schein Buys Majority Interest In Prism Medical Products
    • Top 10 Trends In The Medical Device And Equipment Industry
    • Masimo Earns CE Mark For New Fingertip Pulse Oximeter
    Breaking News
    • Kwivik Therapeutics, EirMed Partner to Accelerate Product Commercialization
    • Europe Marks its First Successful Remote Robotic-Assisted Coronary Angioplasty
    • Twist on Heart Valve Design Boosts Blood Flow, Prevents Clots
    • FDA Clears 3D Acellular Dermal Matrix
    • Inogen to Undergo Leadership Transition
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    November/December 2020

    • Pharmaceutical Focus: A Look at Combination Products
    • The Printed World: Additive Manufacturing in Medtech
    • The Lost Year: 2020 Year in Review
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    Omega-3s Evidenced to Reduce Low-Grade Inflammation in Elderly Men
    MIND and Mediterranean Diets Linked to Later Onset of Parkinson’s Disease
    Kerry Launches Web-Based Tool for Plant-Based Formulation Challenges
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    IFS Coatings Launches IFS Puroplaz PE20 Texture
    Keyland Polymer UV Powder, LLC Launches UVMax Defender
    Scott McLaughlin to Race in PPG Colors During Rookie INDYCAR Season
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Kwivik Therapeutics, EirMed Partner to Accelerate Product Commercialization
    Europe Marks its First Successful Remote Robotic-Assisted Coronary Angioplasty
    Twist on Heart Valve Design Boosts Blood Flow, Prevents Clots
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Novartis Invests in Credence MedSystems
    Ajinomoto Bio-Pharma, Humanigen Expand Manufacturing Agreement
    Almac Expands Global Biologics Testing Services
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    Coty to Shut Down Manufacturing Site in Cologne, Germany
    L’Occitane Files for Bankruptcy in U.S.
    Bésame Cosmetics Collaborates with Disney on Mary Poppins Collection
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    HI Beach Installs Reef-friendly Sunscreen Dispenser
    RB Partners with Airbnb
    L'Occitane US Files for Bankruptcy
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Epson Partner Creates Label Applicators for Pharmaceutical Products
    Smurfit Kappa Sets New Sustainability Targets with Better Planet 2050
    Georgia-Pacific Acquires 3rd HP PageWide Corrugated Press to Expand Hummingbird Digital Printing
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Fix-A-Form eyes global expansion
    McCracken Label installs Fujifilm water-wash plate system
    Schreiner MediPharm introduces syringe label with enhanced safety
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Nice-Pak Receives EPA Approval for Disinfecting Wipes
    Rockline to Invest $18 Million in Arkansas
    American Made Production Equipment for Mask Manufacturers
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    ChoiceSpine's Tiger Shark Cervical Spacer Earns Additional 510(k)
    FDA Green Lights Inspired Spine's Trident SI Joint Screw System
    FDA Clears Method to Extract Bone Measurements From X-Rays
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    North American Semiconductor Equipment Industry Posts December 2020 Billings
    Midsummer Signs Cooperation Agreement in Spanish Market
    First Solar Signs Definitive Agreement to Sell US Development Platform to Leeward

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login