• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Opinions
    • Top 30
    • Research
    • Supply Chain
    • Device Sectors
    • Directory
    • Events
    • Resources
    • Microsites
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Top 30
  • Research
  • Supply Chain
  • Device Sectors
  • Directory
  • Events
  • Resources
  • Microsites
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Reprints
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Seeking a Revolution in Clinical Care Through AI

    Diversifying Supply Chains: New Opportunities Post Pandemic and After Brexit

    Addition by Subtraction: The Latest of Machining for Medtech

    Innovation Incubators: An R&D Roundtable

    Virtual Allies: Electronics Manufacturing Services Providers Offer Real Solutions
    OEM News
    Supplier News
    Service / Press Releases
    Online Exclusives
    Press Releases
    People in the News
    Product & Service Releases
    Supplier News
    Medtech Makers
    Technical Features
    International News
    Videos
    Product & Service Releases
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Philips, Disney Join Forces to Reduce Childrens' MRI Anxiety

    FDA OKs Asensus' Senhance for General Surgery

    Boston Scientific to Buy Lumenis' Surgical Biz for $1B

    Medtech M&A Total Deal Value Plummets in Q4 2020

    Dexcom Launches Inaugural Venture Capital Fund
    From the Editor
    Blogs
    Guest Opinions
    Top Opinions
    Seeking a Revolution in Clinical Care Through AI

    Diversifying Supply Chains: New Opportunities Post Pandemic and After Brexit

    Addition by Subtraction: The Latest of Machining for Medtech

    Innovation Incubators: An R&D Roundtable

    Virtual Allies: Electronics Manufacturing Services Providers Offer Real Solutions
    Top 30 Medical Device Companies
    Market Data
    White Papers
    Top Research
    Five Themes to Watch as Digital Health Takes Center Stage

    Rethink Your Medtech ASC Strategy, Part 1

    Pandemic-Level Playing Field: How COVID-19 Made Space for Progress

    Tips for Reigniting Your MDR/IVDR Preparation

    Three Major Innovation Opportunities for Biomedical Textiles
    3D/Additive Manufacturing
    Contract Manufacturing
    Electronics
    Machining & Laser Processing
    Materials
    Molding
    Packaging & Sterilization
    R&D & Design
    Software & IT
    Testing
    Tubing & Extrusion
    Cardiovascular
    Diagnostics
    Digital Health
    Neurological
    Patient Monitoring
    Surgical
    Orthopedics
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Capabilities
    Add New Company
    Outsourcing Directory
    Medbio LLC

    Forefront Medical Technology

    Creganna Medical, part of TE Connectivity

    PTI Engineered Plastics Inc.

    FUTEK Advanced Sensor Technology Inc.
    MPO Summit
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live From Show Event
    Industry Associations
    Videos
    Career Central
    eBook
    Slideshows
    Top Resources
    How Grant Funding Works and How It Can Help

    Refurbished Medical Equipment Testing and Certification Under the NEC

    Taking the First Step with Metal Components

    4 Trends Driving Medical Manufacturing in 2021

    Pioneering AI Solutions to Reinforce Healthcare Services
    Companies
    News Releases
    Product Releases
    Press Releases
    Product Spec Sheets
    Service Releases
    Case Studies
    White Papers
    Brochures
    Videos
    Outsourcing Directory
    Forefront Medical Technology

    Medbio LLC

    Unicep

    Spectrum Plastics Group

    MW Life Sciences
    • Magazine
      • Current/Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Editions
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • News
    • Directory
      • All Companies
      • ALL CATEGORIES
      • Industry Associations
      • Company Capabilities
      • Add Your Company
    • Supply Chain
      • 3D/Additive Manufacturing
      • Contract Manufacturing
      • Electronics
      • Machining & Laser Processing
      • Materials
      • Molding
      • Packaging & Sterilization
      • R&D & Design
      • Software & IT
      • Testing
      • Tubing & Extrusion
    • Device Sectors
      • Cardiovascular
      • Diagnostics
      • Digital Health
      • Neurological
      • Patient Monitoring
      • Surgical
      • Orthopedics
    • Top 30 Company Report
    • Expert Insights
    • Slideshows
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Resources
    • eBook
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Research
      • White Papers
      • Case Studies
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Market Data
    • MPO Summit
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Microsite
      • Companies
      • Product Releases
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Services
      • White Papers / Tech Papers
      • Press Releases
      • Videos
      • Literature / Brochures
      • Case Studies
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise with Us
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Columns

    Shop Smart: How to Make the Most of the Prototype Phase

    ...

    Shop Smart: How to Make the Most of the Prototype Phase
    Related CONTENT
    • Evolving Trends in the Medical and Orthopedic Devices Industry
    • Report: Emergency Use Authorization a Top Health Hazard for 2021
    • Solvay Partners With PrinterPrezz on 3D Printing for Medical Devices
    • Researchers Develop New Combined Process for 3D Printing
    • 4D Biomaterials Awarded Funding for 3D Tissue Scaffolds
    Dawn A. Lissy, President & Founder, Empirical01.30.18
    There are two basic types of people: Those who make sweeping generalizations, and those who don’t. (Actually, there’s a third type—one who opens columns with corny jokes and strains to hear the laugh track over the lonely cricket in the corner.)

    Jokes aside, we do find two primary types of clients relating to the prototyping phase of medical device development. I like to think of them as “additive” or “subtractive” types. Not to be confused with the physical processes to generate a prototype, these are people who either have a solid concept of what a prototype should be, or customers who need to see a wide range of options before knowing what they do or don’t like.

    It helps the Empirical Machine staff to ascertain at the start which type we’re dealing with. It aids the client as well, because it’s two very different approaches to supporting their device development.

    Developers with a clear idea of what they want can potentially create a functional prototype faster than the client who needs to see 9,999 ways to not make an implant because we’re adding minor changes to a fairly solid concept. However, the “additive” customer might be fixated on an idea that doesn’t necessarily address all the other prototyping aspects we consider at Empirical.

    For the “subtractive” set, we often find ourselves generating multiple versions of the same prototype because these clients won’t know if we’re on the right track until it’s in front of them. This type of open discovery process can become especially time-consuming. However, it also allows greater flexibility and input from outsiders with expertise on the big picture of getting a medical device to market.

    Richard Brown, senior engineer at Engineering & Quality Solutions Inc. (EQS), knows each client type well. We frequently partner with EQS on projects for which Empirical provides testing and small-batch manufacturing and EQS supplies product development or engineering analysis. Richard has over 30 years of experience in the design and manufacturing world and has prototyped hundreds of parts. Engineering & Quality Solutions Inc. offers FEA and engineering analysis, product development support, and FDA and quality systems expertise. He said before beginning the prototype phase, make a thorough, honest assessment of your goals, budget, and the project’s scope.

    “To get the most out of doing a prototype, you really need to understand what the need for the prototype is,” he said. “You might just need a quick couple of ‘touchy-feely’ parts to put into someone’s hands. You might not need all of the geometry or even all of the function out of it yet.”

    You also need to determine if the prototype better lends itself to traditional manufacturing, 3D printing, or a combination, Brown said.

    “Cost, material, geometry, purpose of prototype, and type of part are all considerations,” he said. “Just about any traditionally manufactured part can be 3D printed, but does it need to be?”

    3D printing is almost always going to offer faster and, in many cases, cheaper prototyping. But those prototypes may not have full function, proper cosmetics, etc. Traditional machining can produce a fully functioning part. If it is likely to be the final manufacturing process, prototyping with traditional machining can be a critical test run to reveal potential device production issues and unforeseen costs.

    A prototype with functional threads may be an issue for additive processes. The prototype’s build size may be better suited for traditional manufacturing. Porous structures often work better with additive manufacturing so the device’s density can be adjusted based on clinical need. Materials can be an issue as well. While material variety is certainly expanding in the additive manufacturing industry, there are still some limitations. It also used to be considerably more expensive to opt for 3D printing, but now that’s not necessarily the case.

    “You’re getting to the point [where] I think it’s a definite quote process,” Brown said. “Additive can give traditional a good run for the money, depending on material type, size of the part, type of part, things like that.”

    If your goal is a functional prototype and/or to gain insight into the long-term manufacturing outlook, there are a couple of deal-breaker questions to address with your vendor: Is the shop ISO 13485 certified, and are they registered with the FDA and operating according to regulation 21 CFR part 820?

    “That is the absolutely the first thing you need to ask,” Brown said. “If they don’t know what that is, you need to go elsewhere. You have a lot of people and a lot of machine shops that are doing medical implants that I will say probably shouldn’t be because they don’t realize all of the concerns related to the FDA.”

    If the answers are yes and yes, show that vendor your drawings before commencing in order to unearth whether anything in the design requires special tools or unexpected customization.

    “You’re looking for any information you can get out of the shop at this point,” Brown said. “Find out if they’re seeing anything that can save money or that might help improve cost and manufacturability.”

    When working with a 3D printer, determine if that particular shop uses materials necessary for your prototype and whether they use electron beam or laser sintering. Outsourcing additive manufacturing can be especially tricky in our industry because the FDA is still developing standards for these newer manufacturing technologies. We have yet to find a vendor actually specializing in medical devices. (See “3D Printing: Third Industrial Revolution or Productivity Stalemate?” in the October 2016 issue of MPO). That will likely change as developers continue to more frequently and aptly use this manufacturing process. Expect a learning curve—most 3D printing vendors are still learning about our industry and requirements as they take on projects.

    Whenever possible, think with the final product in mind. Work out whatever issues exist with regard to ease of manufacturing to scale in the prototype phase before reaching mass production.

    “Ask your vendor or machine shop, ‘What are you seeing here that I can change that might make your life easier?’” Brown said. “Have I designed something special into this where they’re going to need a special tool or material size to manufacture what I need?”

    Sometimes a simple design tweak so the device can be produced with standard tools or a change to a standard material size will save considerable time, money, and regulatory questions.

    Consider overall tolerances. If you have a mating part, designing a standard-sized hole means standard-sized tools can shape that part. Even 0.001 inches can have an impact on your timeline and budget, and a nonstandard hole may not be important for that version of prototype.

    “As we get closer and nearer to final prototype, we’re hoping it’s perfect,” Brown said.

    We all hope for “perfect,” but I’m happy with “really freakin’ close”—safe, reproducible, on time, and on budget. Approaching the prototype phase with equal commitment to thorough due diligence as to your entire project and asking the right questions of the right partner will get you there. 


    Dawn Lissy is a biomedical engineer, entrepreneur, and innovator. Since 1998, the Empirical family of companies (Empirical Testing Corp., Empirical Consulting, LLC, and Empirical Machine, LLC) has operated under Lissy’s direction. Empirical offers the full range of regulatory and quality systems consulting, testing, small batch and prototype manufacturing, and validations services to bring a medical device to market. Empirical is very active within standards development organization ASTM International and has one of the widest scopes of test methods of any accredited independent lab in the United States. Because Lissy was a member of the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s Entrepreneur-in-Residence program, she has first-hand, in-depth knowledge of the regulatory landscape. Lissy holds an inventor patent for the Stackable Cage System for corpectomy and vertebrectomy. Her M.S. in biomedical engineering is from The University of Akron, Ohio.
    Related Searches
    • additive manufacturing
    • standard
    • 3d printing
    • implant
    Related Knowledge Center
    • R&D & Design
    Suggested For You
    Evolving Trends in the Medical and Orthopedic Devices Industry Evolving Trends in the Medical and Orthopedic Devices Industry
    Report: Emergency Use Authorization a Top Health Hazard for 2021 Report: Emergency Use Authorization a Top Health Hazard for 2021
    Solvay Partners With PrinterPrezz on 3D Printing for Medical Devices Solvay Partners With PrinterPrezz on 3D Printing for Medical Devices
    Researchers Develop New Combined Process for 3D Printing Researchers Develop New Combined Process for 3D Printing
    4D Biomaterials Awarded Funding for 3D Tissue Scaffolds 4D Biomaterials Awarded Funding for 3D Tissue Scaffolds
    DURECT to Sell LACTEL Absorbable Polymer to Evonik for $15M DURECT to Sell LACTEL Absorbable Polymer to Evonik for $15M
    Social Distancing Badge Lights Way to Return to Work Social Distancing Badge Lights Way to Return to Work
    Empirical Technologies Corp. Empirical Technologies Corp.
    Biodegradable 3D Printed Stents Treat Esophageal Inflammation Biodegradable 3D Printed Stents Treat Esophageal Inflammation
    Medtech Makers: Collaborating with Full-Service Design and Development Providers Medtech Makers: Collaborating with Full-Service Design and Development Providers
    Pharmaceutical Focus: A Look at Combination Products Pharmaceutical Focus: A Look at Combination Products
    The Printed World: Additive Manufacturing in Medtech The Printed World: Additive Manufacturing in Medtech
    Quality Assurance When Supply Chain Disruptions Arise Quality Assurance When Supply Chain Disruptions Arise
    Additive Manufacturing: Debinding Fluids Must-Haves Additive Manufacturing: Debinding Fluids Must-Haves
    Qosina Partners with Resolution Medical to Offer a 3D-Printed Sterile Nasal Swab for COVID-19 Testing Qosina Partners with Resolution Medical to Offer a 3D-Printed Sterile Nasal Swab for COVID-19 Testing

    Related Columns

    • R&D & Design
      Pandemic-Level Playing Field: How COVID-19 Made Space for Progress

      Pandemic-Level Playing Field: How COVID-19 Made Space for Progress

      Pandemic restrictions may have diminished certain advantages large companies hold over small and mid-sized competitors.
      Dawn A. Lissy, President & Founder, Empirical 02.03.21

    • Contract Manufacturing | R&D & Design
      Trends for Medtech Contract R&D and Manufacturing

      Trends for Medtech Contract R&D and Manufacturing

      Over the past 10 years, medtech manufacturers from startups to giants have grown their levels of outsourcing to contract R&D and manufacturing partners.
      Maria Shepherd, President and Founder, Medi-Vantage 09.01.20

    • R&D & Design | Surgical
      Sparking Innovation as We Struggle to Find the New Normal

      Sparking Innovation as We Struggle to Find the New Normal

      The goal is to find the best ideas to support orthopedic patients adjusting to additional pain and immobility while they wait for elective surgeries.
      Dawn A. Lissy, Founder & President, Empirical 06.04.20


    • R&D & Design
      Disposable Design: Consider All Interfaces

      Disposable Design: Consider All Interfaces

      The disposable component is becoming more challenging as products get smaller and more complex.
      Will DeMore, Mechanical Engineer, Key Technologies Inc. 06.04.20

    • R&D & Design
      Why Outsourcing Is in: Piecing Out Projects Makes Sense

      Why Outsourcing Is in: Piecing Out Projects Makes Sense

      Getting outside help is a trend both large and small medical device companies are following as outsourcing engineering services continues to gain traction.
      Dawn A. Lissy, President & Founder, Empirical 04.01.20

    • R&D & Design
      Top 10 Considerations for Medtech Inventors

      Top 10 Considerations for Medtech Inventors

      If you or your employer is interested in protecting an invention, then filing a patent application may be the way to go.
      Ryan Connell and Doug Portnow, Schwegman Lundberg & Woessner 04.01.20


    • R&D & Design
      Supercharge Medical Device Innovation Using Effective User Preference Studies

      Supercharge Medical Device Innovation Using Effective User Preference Studies

      User preference and evaluation studies have been a mainstay design tool for medical device development for decades.
      Philip Remedios, Principal, Director of Design & Development, BlackHägen Design 04.01.20

    • R&D & Design | Testing
      FDA Guidelines for Employing X-ray Inspection in Medical Device Development

      FDA Guidelines for Employing X-ray Inspection in Medical Device Development

      Different materials exhibit different radiopacity as a function of material composition (i.e. atomic weight) and thickness.
      Gil Zweig, President, Glenbrook Technologies 01.29.20

    • Digital Health | R&D & Design
      Speed Up or Risk Stepping Down: The New Reality of the Connected Healthcare Development Cycle

      Speed Up or Risk Stepping Down: The New Reality of the Connected Healthcare Development Cycle

      Digital health and connected devices are an extraordinary new tool for delivering on improving patient outcomes.
      Joe McBeth, VP Global Supply Chain, Jabil Healthcare 01.29.20


    • R&D & Design
      Perfecting Drug Delivery Device Design

      Perfecting Drug Delivery Device Design

      Unlike medical products that just need to work, drug delivery devices must also consider intuitiveness, usability, and how it makes the user feel when operated.
      Bryce G. Rutter, Ph.D., Founder & CEO, Metaphase Design Group Inc. 11.04.19

    • R&D & Design
      Best Practices for Industrial Design in the Medical Device Space

      Best Practices for Industrial Design in the Medical Device Space

      This article will outline unique concerns in the medical space and how proper attention to special design considerations is critical.
      Bartosz Korec, Lead Industrial Designer, BlackHägen Design 10.08.19

    • R&D & Design
      Three Crucial Elements of Conducting International Usability Research

      Three Crucial Elements of Conducting International Usability Research

      It is important to conduct usability research throughout the product development cycle.
      Joe Pratt, CHFP, Lead Human Factors Engineer, BlackHägen Design 09.06.19


    • Materials | Packaging & Sterilization | R&D & Design
      Case in Point: Robust Sintered PTFE Material Helps to Reduce Risk of HAIs

      Case in Point: Robust Sintered PTFE Material Helps to Reduce Risk of HAIs

      ...
      Jack Chan, Global Marketing Director—Medical, Porex 07.30.19

    • R&D & Design
      What Is Human Factors Engineering and Why Is It Important?

      What Is Human Factors Engineering and Why Is It Important?

      ...
      Rich Newman, Usability Engineering Manager, BlackHägen Design 07.30.19

    • R&D & Design
      Designing for a Seamless UX

      Designing for a Seamless UX

      ...
      Dr. Bryce Rutter, Founder and CEO, Metaphase Design Group Inc. 06.13.19


    Trending
    • FDA Breakthrough Device Designation Awarded To BrainCool AB's Cooral System
    • Mike On Medtech: Update On FDA's STeP Designation
    • Hardy Diagnostics Releases Rapid Test For COVID-19
    • Quidel's QuickVue At-Home COVID-19 Test Earns EUA
    • NAMSA Acquires American Preclinical Services
    Breaking News
    • Ready Robotics Hires Proven Automation Leaders
    • Philips, Disney Join Forces to Reduce Childrens' MRI Anxiety
    • FDA OKs Asensus' Senhance for General Surgery
    • Boston Scientific to Buy Lumenis' Surgical Biz for $1B
    • Medtech M&A Total Deal Value Plummets in Q4 2020
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    January/February 2021

    • Seeking a Revolution in Clinical Care Through AI
    • Diversifying Supply Chains: New Opportunities Post Pandemic and After Brexit
    • Addition by Subtraction: The Latest of Machining for Medtech
    • Innovation Incubators: An R&D Roundtable
    • Virtual Allies: Electronics Manufacturing Services Providers Offer Real Solutions
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    Study Explains Link Between Probiotic Strains and Children’s Immune Health Benefits
    Maypro Launches Brain Heatlh Ingredient NeuroHD
    Gadot Biochemical Launches New Magnesium Ingredients
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    Chromaflo Technologies Adds Benjamin Woeste as Territory Sales Manager
    Matt Fogel Named Mule-Hide's Territory Manager – Southern Virginia
    Benjamin Moore Launches COMMAND
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    Ready Robotics Hires Proven Automation Leaders
    Philips, Disney Join Forces to Reduce Childrens' MRI Anxiety
    FDA OKs Asensus' Senhance for General Surgery
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Innoforce and dMed Enter Development Collaboration
    Matica Biotechnology Breaks Ground on Cell and Gene Therapy Site
    Four Female Leaders Appointed to Cell & Gene CDMO
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    BizBash Names Unfiltered Experience ‘People's Choice: Best Influencer Event’
    P&G Makes Progress Toward Packaging Circularity in Europe
    Coty Partners with LanzaTech to Introduce Sustainable Ethanol
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Uoma Beauty Unveils a Coming 2 America Makeup Collaboration
    Coty Partners with LanzaTech to Reduce Its Environmental Impact
    Waterless Beauty, Simplified Routines Shape Clean Beauty at Whole Foods
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Massilly North America Adds Koenig & Bauer MetalStar 3 Metal Decorating Press
    Hydrocarbon Solvents Market to Surpass $8.1 Billion by 2030
    Access Direct Mail Doubles Revenue with SCREEN's Truepress Jet520HD
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Ashland announces PSA price hike in North America
    Arrow Systems and Sihl form flexible packaging partnership
    Flint Group Packaging announces global price increase
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Joa Announces Expandable Absorbent Core Wrap Solution
    Principle Business Enterprises Celebrates 60 Years
    Mann+Hummel Invests in Pamlico Air
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Lincotek Medical Expands Coatings and Additive Capacity
    Spinal Elements Relaunches the Luna XD and Orbit Systems
    Coronavirus Triggers Double-Digit Revenue Dropoff at Smith+Nephew
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    Comercial Kywi Improves Customer Service, Front-Store Operations with Zebra Mobile Solution
    Global Printed Circuit Board Market Projected to Reach $69.32 Billion by 2027
    Global Smart Glass Market to Register 6.8% CAGR Between 2021-28: Grand View Research

    Copyright © 2021 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login