• Login
    • Join
  • FOLLOW:
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Opinions
    • Top 30
    • Research
    • Supply Chain
    • Device Sectors
    • Directory
    • Events
    • Resources
    • Microsites
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Opinions
  • Top 30
  • Research
  • Supply Chain
  • Device Sectors
  • Directory
  • Events
  • Resources
  • Microsites
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Our Team
    Editorial Guidelines
    Reprints
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    6 Ways ERP Systems Help Medical Device Manufacturers Manage Risk and Profitability

    Machining & Laser Processing Have Huge Parts to Play in Medtech Manufacturing

    Medtech R&D Teams Must Be Creative & Resilient to Survive

    Struggling Suppliers in Electronics Manufacturing Services (EMS)

    Deep (Brain) Thoughts with Medtronic's Neuromodulation President
    OEM News
    Supplier News
    Service / Press Releases
    Online Exclusives
    Press Releases
    People in the News
    Product & Service Releases
    Supplier News
    Medtech Makers
    Technical Features
    International News
    Videos
    Product & Service Releases
    Live From Shows
    Regulatory
    Financial/Business
    Top News
    MPO's Most-Read Stories This Week—Feb. 4

    MO SCI Acquires Assets of 3M’s Advanced Materials Business

    Neurent Medical’s NEUROMARK System Becomes Commercially Available in U.S. Markets

    Aspivix's Carevix Cervical Stabilizer Gains FDA OK

    Apyx Medical Submits 510(k) App for Renuvion APR Handpiece
    From the Editor
    Blogs
    Guest Opinions
    Top Opinions
    6 Ways ERP Systems Help Medical Device Manufacturers Manage Risk and Profitability

    Machining & Laser Processing Have Huge Parts to Play in Medtech Manufacturing

    Medtech R&D Teams Must Be Creative & Resilient to Survive

    Struggling Suppliers in Electronics Manufacturing Services (EMS)

    Deep (Brain) Thoughts with Medtronic's Neuromodulation President
    Top 30 Medical Device Companies
    Market Data
    White Papers
    Top Research
    Deducing the Dual Reality of Elizabeth Holmes

    The Return of the AdvaMed MedTech Conference…Live!

    Material Matters: New Materials Call for New Thinking

    5 Ways to Maintain a Talent-Centric Mindset, Even During Economic Uncertainty

    The Changing Face of UK Medical Device Regulations: Most Recent Update
    3D/Additive Manufacturing
    Contract Manufacturing
    Electronics
    Machining & Laser Processing
    Materials
    Molding
    Packaging & Sterilization
    R&D & Design
    Software & IT
    Testing
    Tubing & Extrusion
    Cardiovascular
    Diagnostics
    Digital Health
    Neurological
    Patient Monitoring
    Surgical
    Orthopedics
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Capabilities
    Add New Company
    Outsourcing Directory
    NDH Medical Inc.

    Arthur G. Russell Co. Inc., The

    Paragon Medical

    LEMO USA Inc.

    Fusion Biotec Inc.
    MPO Summit
    Industry Events
    Webinars
    Live From Show Event
    Industry Associations
    Videos
    Career Central
    eBook
    Slideshows
    Top Resources
    Onshoring Medical Device Manufacturing Can Strengthen Supply Chains

    How Artificial Intelligence Can Combat Key Issues Impacting Healthcare

    Why Advanced Sensors Are Crucial Within Medical Pumps

    How Artificial Intelligence Could Help Prevent 80% of Chronic Diseases

    4 Ways to Use Injection Molding in Medical Device Manufacturing
    Companies
    News Releases
    Product Releases
    Press Releases
    Product Spec Sheets
    Service Releases
    Case Studies
    White Papers
    Brochures
    Videos
    Outsourcing Directory
    NDH Medical Inc.

    Arthur G. Russell Co. Inc., The

    Paragon Medical

    LEMO USA Inc.

    Fusion Biotec Inc.
    • Magazine
      • Current/Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Editions
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • News
    • Directory
      • All Companies
      • ALL CATEGORIES
      • Industry Associations
      • Company Capabilities
      • Add Your Company
    • Supply Chain
      • 3D/Additive Manufacturing
      • Contract Manufacturing
      • Electronics
      • Machining & Laser Processing
      • Materials
      • Molding
      • Packaging & Sterilization
      • R&D & Design
      • Software & IT
      • Testing
      • Tubing & Extrusion
    • Device Sectors
      • Cardiovascular
      • Diagnostics
      • Digital Health
      • Neurological
      • Patient Monitoring
      • Surgical
      • Orthopedics
    • Top 30 Company Report
    • Expert Insights
    • Slideshows
    • Videos
    • eBook
    • Resources
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Research
      • White Papers
      • Case Studies
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Market Data
    • MPO Summit
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
    • Microsite
      • Companies
      • Product Releases
      • Product Spec Sheets
      • Services
      • White Papers / Tech Papers
      • Press Releases
      • Videos
      • Literature / Brochures
      • Case Studies
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise with Us
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Online Exclusives

    Supreme Changes for ‘Single-Use’ Patent Law

    Recent changes to the Patent Exhaustion Doctrine to impact the medical device community.

    Supreme Changes for ‘Single-Use’ Patent Law
    Related Content
    • FDA Warns BD About Blood Collection Tubes Used in Lead Testing Kit
    • FDA Issues Class I Recall for Sterilmed Reprocessed Agilis Steerable Introducer Sheath
    • Regulatory Approval Pathway for Biomaterials—Mike on Medtech
    • IP Veteran Joins BioSig Technologies’ Board of Directors
    • FDA Announces 3D Printed Medical Device Guidance
    Cheryl Burgess, Partner, Knobbe Martens01.26.18
    A patent owner has the right to exclude others from making, using, selling, offering for sale, and importing a patented product. However, an unqualified sale of a patented product terminates the patent owner’s rights under patent law to control the patented article under the doctrine of patent exhaustion (also called the first sale doctrine). Historically, legal precedent permitted lawful restrictions on post-sale use or resale to preserve patent rights. Although a patent owner could not prevent redistribution of his patented product, he could place contractual restrictions on how customers used or distributed the patented product. A patent owner’s patent rights were deemed preserved against uses that violated such contractual restrictions. Additional legal precedent held that foreign sales did not exhaust U.S. patent rights.
     
    The Supreme Court’s Lexmark Decision
    The Supreme Court changed the law this past May in Impression Products Inc. v. Lexmark International Inc. Lexmark sold ink-toner cartridges for use in laser printers to customers worldwide. In an attempt to prevent unauthorized refilling and reselling of spent cartridges, Lexmark imposed a contractual obligation on U.S. customers to use a cartridge only once and to refrain from giving the empty cartridge to anyone but Lexmark. Impression Products purchased used cartridges from Lexmark’s customers, refilled them, and resold them in the U.S. at a lower price than Lexmark. Lexmark sued Impression Products for patent infringement. The Federal Circuit held that the patent exhaustion doctrine did not prevent Lexmark from retaining the right to enforce its patent against resale of its product if lawful restrictions where placed on such resale. The Federal Circuit also held that patent exhaustion only applied to Lexmark’s domestic sales. The Supreme Court granted certiorari and reversed the Federal Circuit, holding that a patentee’s decision to sell a patented product, domestically or abroad, exhausts all of the patent rights in the product.
     
    How Lexmark Impacts the Medical Device Community
    The Supreme Court’s decision affects technologies well beyond the refurbished printer cartridges at issue in Lexmark. Many medical devices are designed, labeled, and expressly sold as “single-use only.” For medical devices that are not “single-use only,” suppliers may still wish to restrict the downstream use, resale, or refurbishment in some manner. A medical device patent owner may wish to impose single-use and other restrictions for reasons of product efficacy, patient safety, or to meet specific FDA requirements. Medical device patent owners have relied for decades on the ability to impose lawful restrictions on post-sale use or resale, and to use patent rights to enforce such restrictions. Lexmark restricts the ability of these medical device patent owners to do so.
     
    The World Post-Lexmark
    The Supreme Court’s decision leaves open two avenues for a patent owner to exercise downstream control of patented products. First, restrictions on licensees remain lawful. An authorized sale by a licensee will extinguish patent rights to the same extent as an initial sale by the patentee, but an unauthorized sale will not extinguish such rights. A comparison of two recent district court cases illustrates this point. In Miics & Partners Am. Inc. v. Toshiba Corp.(D. Del. 2017), Miics licensed Samsung and Panasonic to sell LCD components. The license agreements prohibited Samsung and Panasonic from making end-user products with the LCD components. Samsung and Panasonic sold the LCD components to Toshiba and Funai, who incorporated them into end-user products. The district court dismissed Miics’ infringement suit against Toshiba and Funai because Miics’ rights in the asserted patents were exhausted by authorized sales. The license agreements limited Samsung’s and Panasonic’s ability to manufacture end-user products, but did not limit to whom Samsung and Panasonic could sell the licensed products. Compare Miics to Sunoco Partners Mktg. v. U.S. Venture Inc. (N.D. Ill. 2017). In Sunoco, as part of a litigation-driven settlement agreement, Sunoco granted Technics Inc. a covenant not to sue for past infringement. The district court held that Technics’ sale of accused infringing products to U.S. Venture prior to the lawsuit did not exhaust Sunoco’s patent rights; a sale must still be authorized by the patent owner to trigger patent exhaustion. Another district court in Chrimar Sys. v. Alcatel-Lucent Enter. USA Inc. (E.D. Tex. 2017) similarly reaffirmed that a license that restricts the licensee from selling products to particular third parties is still valid.
     
    Thus, medical device manufacturers may be able to institute more complex licensing structures to impose certain post-sale restrictions on patented devices. But there are many as yet unanswered questions on how far such restrictions may extend. For example, can a patent owner avoid exhaustion by forming a separate manufacturing entity licensed to make and sell patented devices only to customers that will discard the device after a single use? Not likely, given that the Supreme Court’s Lexmark decision was an outgrowth of the law’s preference against restraints on alienation. Attempts to use a license to impose post-sale restrictions on purchasers that could not be imposed by the patent owner directly will be heavily scrutinized.
     
    In addition to restrictions on licensees, the Supreme Court’s decision leaves open the possibility that post-sale restrictions are enforceable under contract law. Contract law may provide some help, but is largely an impractical remedy. Contract law cannot offer the same breadth of remedies to a patent owner as an infringement suit. A patent owner may impose contractual penalties on those with whom it is in privity of contract (i.e., direct customers) to dissuade the transfer of used single-use products or to encourage other post-sale restrictions on product use. The advisability of launching a lawsuit against a direct customer is questionable at best. As for subsequent purchasers, contract law is largely ineffective in enforcing contractual restrictions against those who were not parties to the original contract containing the restrictions. Even if there is contractual privity between the patent owner and a subsequent purchaser, available contractual remedies may provide only monetary damages, not the injunctive relief necessary to prevent reconditioned devices from entering the market. Moreover, preemption might bar some state law breach of contract claims. Efforts to enforce contractual restrictions may also run afoul of antitrust, patent misuse, and unfair competition law principles in the wake of Lexmark.
     
    In short, Lexmark makes it difficult for a patent owner to go after downstream purchasers that disregard initial sales conditions. Accordingly, patent owners must adapt their strategies. Patent owners should focus pricing and royalty policies on the first authorized sale, remembering that an authorized foreign purchaser may import the patented product into the U.S. and any authorized purchaser may resell the product in the U.S. Suppliers of single-use products may want to incorporate technological limitations on further product use that make it impossible, or at least costly and impractical, for downstream purchasers to reuse or refurbish products (e.g., microchips that prevent reuse after a set time or event occurrence). For durable products, suppliers may want to lease in lieu of selling a patented product. A bona fide lease transaction may indeed avoid patent exhaustion, but will raise additional financial, accounting, liability, and insurance concerns. A purported lease that is no more than a thinly disguised sale is unlikely to avoid patent exhaustion.
     

    Cheryl Burgess is a partner in the Orange County, Calif., office of intellectual property law firm Knobbe Martens.
    Related Searches
    • Manufacturing
    • panasonic
    • safety
    • manufacture
    Suggested For You
    FDA Warns BD About Blood Collection Tubes Used in Lead Testing Kit FDA Warns BD About Blood Collection Tubes Used in Lead Testing Kit
    FDA Issues Class I Recall for Sterilmed Reprocessed Agilis Steerable Introducer Sheath FDA Issues Class I Recall for Sterilmed Reprocessed Agilis Steerable Introducer Sheath
    Regulatory Approval Pathway for Biomaterials—Mike on Medtech Regulatory Approval Pathway for Biomaterials—Mike on Medtech
    IP Veteran Joins BioSig Technologies’ Board of Directors IP Veteran Joins BioSig Technologies’ Board of Directors
    FDA Announces 3D Printed Medical Device Guidance FDA Announces 3D Printed Medical Device Guidance
    RSNA News: Toshiba Medical Launches New MR to Enhance Patient Comfort in Community Hospital Settings RSNA News: Toshiba Medical Launches New MR to Enhance Patient Comfort in Community Hospital Settings
    Quality Nightmares #32 Quality Nightmares #32
     Samsung Unveils New Mobile CT OmniTom at RSNA 2017 Samsung Unveils New Mobile CT OmniTom at RSNA 2017
    RSNA News:  Toshiba Medical Expands Neuro MR Capabilities with Advanced Gradient Offering RSNA News: Toshiba Medical Expands Neuro MR Capabilities with Advanced Gradient Offering
    Quality Nightmares #31 Quality Nightmares #31
    Pre-Sub with the FDA—Mike on Medtech Pre-Sub with the FDA—Mike on Medtech
    Quality Nightmares #30 Quality Nightmares #30
    FDA’s Role in Medical Device Cybersecurity FDA’s Role in Medical Device Cybersecurity
    FDA Reaches Agreement with Philips North America Over Quality Control Issues FDA Reaches Agreement with Philips North America Over Quality Control Issues
    Flexible Batteries a Highlight for Smart Dental Aids Flexible Batteries a Highlight for Smart Dental Aids

    Related Breaking News

    • Diagnostics
      FDA Warns BD About Blood Collection Tubes Used in Lead Testing Kit

      FDA Warns BD About Blood Collection Tubes Used in Lead Testing Kit

      Modified versions of BD Vacutainer blood collection tubes were marketed without FDA clearance or approval.
      U.S. Food and Drug Administration 01.12.18

    • Cardiovascular
      FDA Issues Class I Recall for Sterilmed Reprocessed Agilis Steerable Introducer Sheath

      FDA Issues Class I Recall for Sterilmed Reprocessed Agilis Steerable Introducer Sheath

      The device is being recalled due to improper seal of the sheath hub.
      U.S. Food and Drug Administration 01.05.18

    • Materials
      Regulatory Approval Pathway for Biomaterials—Mike on Medtech

      Regulatory Approval Pathway for Biomaterials—Mike on Medtech

      Mike Drues and Sean Fenske discuss the potential advantages of implementing an approval pathway for biomaterials.
      Sean Fenske, Editor-in-Chief 01.02.18


    • IP Veteran Joins BioSig Technologies’ Board of Directors

      IP Veteran Joins BioSig Technologies’ Board of Directors

      New member replaces former Celgene Global Health CEO and Celgene Corporation chief medical officer.
      BioSig Technologies Inc. 12.11.17

    • 3D/Additive Manufacturing
      FDA Announces 3D Printed Medical Device Guidance

      FDA Announces 3D Printed Medical Device Guidance

      World’s first agency to provide a comprehensive technical framework for 3D printed medical product manufacturing.
      Scott Gottlieb, M.D., Commissioner, U.S. Food and Drug Administration 12.06.17

    Loading, Please Wait..

    Trending
    • CGM Devices Could Become Main Glucose Monitoring Solution In U.S.
    • Study: Smartphone Therapeutic Helps Improve Fibromyalgia In Patients
    • FDA Clears LiveMetric's Wearable Blood Pressure Monitoring Tech
    • The Future Of Biomedical Engineering Advancements
    • A New Approach To Post-Market Surveillance
    Breaking News
    • MPO's Most-Read Stories This Week—Feb. 4
    • MO SCI Acquires Assets of 3M’s Advanced Materials Business
    • Neurent Medical’s NEUROMARK System Becomes Commercially Available in U.S. Markets
    • Aspivix's Carevix Cervical Stabilizer Gains FDA OK
    • Apyx Medical Submits 510(k) App for Renuvion APR Handpiece
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    January/February 2023

    • Struggling Suppliers in Electronics Manufacturing Services (EMS)
    • Machining & Laser Processing Have Huge Parts to Play
    • Medtech R&D Teams Must Be Creative & Resilient to Survive
    • Medtronic Neuromodulation President, Nnamdi Njoku, Interview
    • 6 Ways ERP Systems Help Medical Device Manufacturers Manage Risk and Profitability
    • View More >

    Cookies help us to provide you with an excellent service. By using our website, you declare yourself in agreement with our use of cookies.
    You can obtain detailed information about the use of cookies on our website by clicking on "More information”.

    • About Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms And Conditions
    • Contact Us

    follow us

    Subscribe
    Nutraceuticals World

    Latest Breaking News From Nutraceuticals World

    GOED Elects New Board Officers for 2023
    Aspire Hires Darrec Jones as VP of Business Development
    Pycnogenol Supplementation Linked to Better Hair Density in Menopausal Women
    Coatings World

    Latest Breaking News From Coatings World

    PPG Completes COLORFUL COMMUNITIES Project in Denmark
    10 Partners of the Automotive Industry Form JV, Cofinity-X
    BASF Recognized as Top Company for Supplier Diversity
    Medical Product Outsourcing

    Latest Breaking News From Medical Product Outsourcing

    MPO's Most-Read Stories This Week—Feb. 4
    MO SCI Acquires Assets of 3M’s Advanced Materials Business
    Neurent Medical’s NEUROMARK System Becomes Commercially Available in U.S. Markets
    Contract Pharma

    Latest Breaking News From Contract Pharma

    Lilly 4Q Revenues Down 9% to $7.3B
    Bionova Expansion Project to Quadruple GMP Biologics Manufacturing Capacity
    Steriline Provides Fill-Finish Solution for Berkshire Sterile Manufacturing
    Beauty Packaging

    Latest Breaking News From Beauty Packaging

    Pacifica Introduces Glow Baby Skincare Line
    Kohl’s Names Tom Kingsbury as Chief Executive Officer
    Mielle Unveils Haircare Bundles Inspired by Amazon Original Series Harlem
    Happi

    Latest Breaking News From Happi

    Glow Balms and Slugging are Top Skincare Trends: Spate
    Curl Care Sales Jump as Consumers Transition to Natural Hairstyles
    Amyris & Tia Mowry’s Haircare Launch, New Product Awards in Beauty and Home Care
    Ink World

    Latest Breaking News From Ink World

    Weekly Recap: Pigments, Inkjet Ink Market Reports Top This Week’s Stories
    Roland DGA Announces Key Changes to Leadership Team
    Ball Reports 2022 Results
    Label & Narrow Web

    Latest Breaking News From Label & Narrow Web

    Brandywine names new president, Brook + Whittle grows and more
    MM Packaging adds first Nilpeter press for Dublin site
    Polytag develops new UV tag reading technology
    Nonwovens Industry

    Latest Breaking News From Nonwovens Industry

    Weekly Recap: K-C Requests Huggies-Related Lawsuit to be Thrown Out, WPT Makes Investment & More
    What You’re Reading on Nonwovens-Industry.com
    Kimberly-Clark Supports Period Poverty Initiative in Australia
    Orthopedic Design & Technology

    Latest Breaking News From Orthopedic Design & Technology

    ODT's Most-Read Stories This Week—Feb. 4
    Toetal Solutions Secures $1.8 Million in New Financing
    Adrian Tyndall Joins Axogen's Board of Directors
    Printed Electronics Now

    Latest Breaking News From Printed Electronics Now

    Weekly Recap: CES 2023, ams OSRAM and Celanese Top This Week’s Stories
    Zebra Provides East West Shrine Bowl with RFID Tracking Technology
    AAAS Elects Three ORNL Scientists as Fellows

    Copyright © 2023 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.

    AD BLOCKER DETECTED

    Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors.
    Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker.


    FREE SUBSCRIPTION Already a subscriber? Login